RSS

Tag Archives: #NoticeandNote

Blending Technology with Paper and Pencil

My geometry class is 1:1 this year; each student has her own MacBook Air. Students share responses to questions digitally in class using TI-Nspire Navigator for Networked Computers. Students explore mathematics using TI-Nspire dynamic graphs and geometry software. Students explore mathematics and share responses digitally using Demos Activity Builder. We use Canvas, an online learning management system, for assignments. We use Google Drive for sharing electronic documents with each other, and we use MathXL, online homework with built-in learning help, to practice mathematics. What place does pencil and paper have in my students’ learning and understanding of mathematics?

Even though many of the tasks that my students do for geometry take place digitally, I am convinced that pencil and paper plays an important role in how much mathematics my students not only learn but also remember. In a Wall Street Journal article, “Can Handwriting Make You Smarter?“, Robert Lee Hotz reports that students who take notes by hand usually outperform students who type notes when assessed more than one day after the class period. Students who type notes quickly type everything the professor says, but students who handwrite notes have to process the information while they are hearing it to select what is important to remember (Hotz 2016).

Hotz cites the work of Mueller and Oppenheimer published in Pyschological Science. Their research studies showed that students who took notes by hand performed better on conceptual questions than those who took notes on a laptop. Students performed about the same on factual questions. Their hypothesis for why is that students who take notes by hand choose which information is important to include in their notes, and so they are able to study “more efficiently” than those who are reviewing an entire typed lecture (Mueller and Oppenheimer 2014). Note: These studies are on college students; I have found little research on grade school students.

For several years now, my students and I have been learning how to learn mathematics using the Standards for Mathematical Practice. MP8, “look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning”, has pushed me to think about having students record what they see instead of just noticing and discussing it.

SMP8 #LL2LU Gough-Wilson

One of the ways that I’ve learned to talk about “look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning” is to ask students to notice what changes and what stays the same as we take a dynamic action on a geometric figure. Consider a recent learning episode from my classroom.

Students were told that our learning intention was “I can look for and express regularity in repeating reasoning”. The content was conceptual development of the equation of a circle in a coordinate plane using the Pythagorean Theorem. I did not share that specific content with students up front, however, because I wanted it to be revealed as the lesson progressed. I showed them a dynamic right triangle in the coordinate plane.

Notice & Note 1.gif

What changes? What stays the same?

I could have let them simply discuss what they noticed. But instead I asked them to “Notice & Note”, using words, pictures, and numbers to write and sketch what they saw.

Then I asked them to share what they noticed with a partner and add to their own notes as desired.

 

Screen Shot 2016-10-07 at 3.37.01 PM.png

Our classroom discussion revealed that the equation of the circle formed by tracing point P was x2 + y2 = 52.

Notice & Note 2.gif

Students continued to “Notice & Note” as they moved a circle around in the coordinate plane. What changes? What stays the same?

 

Notice & Note 3Notice & Note 4

As we moved P around in the coordinate plane, and then as they later moved the circle around in the coordinate plane students noted what they saw. Eventually, students generalized the center-radius form of an equation.

Notice & Note 5.gif

Notice & Note, by Kylene Beers and Robert E. Probst, is a guide of signposts (strategies) for close reading of text. Students are taught signposts to notice while they are reading, and they are asked to stop reading and note what the signpost might imply. “Again & Again” is one signpost. Do you notice an event in the text that keeps happening again and again? Do you notice a phrase in the text that is repeated again and again? Stop reading, note it, and think about what that might mean (Beers and Probst 2013). How might we take advantage of the ways that students are learning to read text in their English Language Arts (ELA) classes to guide students in inquiry based exploration of mathematics?

In her online course, Sunni Brown, author of The Doodle Revolution, states that “Tracking content using imagery, color, word pictures and typography can change the way you understand information and also dramatically increase your level of knowledge and retention” (Brown 2016). How do we make tracking content using words, pictures, and numbers a reality in the 1:1 classroom? My experience is that it doesn’t happen without deliberate emphasis on its importance.

In Reading Nonfiction, Beers and Probst write “When students recognize that nonfiction ought to challenge us, ought to slow us down and make us think, then they’re more likely to become close readers” (Beers and Probst 2016). Our ELA counterparts are on to something. Effective classroom instruction is not just about creating learning episodes for our students to experience the mathematics using the Math Practices. Effective classroom instruction incorporates practices that will help students remember what they are learning longer than for the next test.

 

As I think about our district’s continued implementation of 1:1 technology, I am convinced that we need to pay attention to when we are asking, encouraging, and requiring students to use pencil and paper to create a record of what they are learning. I am interested in thinking more about how we might blend the use of dynamic graphs and geometry software with Notice & Note – using words, pictures, and numbers, along with color, so that students not only have a record of what they are learning but also have a better chance of remembering it later. And so, the journey continues …


References

Beers, G. Kylene, and Robert E. Probst. Notice & note: Strategies for close reading. Portsmouth: Heinemann, 2013. Print.

Beers, G. K., & Probst, R. E. (2016). Reading nonfiction: Notice & note stances, signposts, and strategies. Portsmouth: Heinemann.

Brown, S. (n.d.). Visual Note-Taking 101 / Personal Infodoodling™. Retrieved April 25, 2016, from http://sunnibrown.com/visualtraining

Hotz, Robert Lee. “Can handwriting make you smarter?” The Wall Street Journal. 04 Apr. 2016. Web. 25 Apr. 2016.

Mueller, P. A., and D. M. Oppenheimer. “The pen is mightier than the keyboard: Advantages of longhand over laptop note taking.” Psychological Science 25.6 (2014): 1159-168. Web.

 
 

Tags: , , , , ,

Notice & Note: Dilations

How do you give your students the opportunity to practice MP8: I can look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning?

SMP8 #LL2LU Gough-Wilson

We started our dilations unit practicing MP8, noticing and noting.

 

Dilations 1.gif

What would you want students to notice and note?

How do students learn what is important to notice and note?

An important consideration when learning with self-explanation is to look at the quality of the explanation itself. What are the students saying or writing? Are they just regurgitating bits of text or making connections to underlying principles? Do the explanations contain predictions about what is going to happen, try to go beyond the given instruction or do they just superficially gloss over what is already there? Students who make principle-based, anticipative, or inference-containing explanations benefit the most from self-explaining. If students seem to be failing to make good explanations, one can try to give prompts with more assistance. In practice, this will likely take iteration by the instructor to figure out what combination of content, activity and prompt provides the most benefit to students. (Chiu & Chi, 2014, p. 99)

We had a brief discussion about what might be important to notice and note. We’ve also been working on predictions, thinking about what you expect to happen before trying it with technology:

What happens when the center of dilation is on the figure, outside the figure, and inside the figure?

Dilations 2.gif

What happens when the scale factor is greater than 1? Equal to 1? Between 0 and 1? Less than 0?

Dilations 3.gif

 

I observed, walking around the room and using Class Capture, selecting conversations for our whole class discussion.

Screenshot 2016-11-11 08.58.34.png

Screenshot 2016-11-11 09.04.53.png

Here’s what NA noticed and noted.

image_123923953

We looked at Hannah’s Rectangle, from NCSM’s Congruence and Similarity PD Module. Students had a straightedge and piece of tracing paper.

Which rectangles are similar to rectangle a? Explain the method you used to decide.Hannahs Rectangle.png

Screenshot 2016-11-11 09.09.47.png

What would you do next? Would you show the correct responses? Or not?

Would you start with an incorrect answer? or a correct answer?

Would you regroup students based on their responses?

Screenshot 2016-11-11 09.12.11.pngScreen Shot 2016-12-19 at 2.21.33 PM.pngScreen Shot 2016-12-19 at 2.28.17 PM.png

I started with a student who didn’t select G and then one who did. Then I asked a student who selected C to share why he chose C and didn’t choose F. We ended by watching Randy’s explanation on the module video.

And so the journey continues, always wondering what comes next (and sometimes wondering what should have come first) …


Chiu, J.L, & Chi, M.T.H. (2014). Supporting self-explanation in the classroom. In V. A. Benassi, C. E. Overson, & C. M. Hakala (Eds.). Applying science of learning in education: Infusing psychological science into the curriculum. Retrieved from the Society for the Teaching of Psychology web site: http://teachpsych.org/ebooks/asle2014/index.php

 

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on December 19, 2016 in Dilations, Geometry

 

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Notice and Note: The Equation of a Circle

I wrote in detail last year about how our students practice I can look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning to make sense of the equation of a circle in the coordinate plane.

This year we took the time not only to notice what changes and what stays the same but also to note what changes and what stays the same.

Our ELA colleagues have been using Notice and Note as a strategy for close reading for a while now. How might we encourage our learners to Notice and Note across disciplines?

Students noticed and noted what stays the same and what changes as we moved point P.

1 03-19-2016 Image005

They made a conjecture about the path P follows, and then we traced point P.

2 03-19-2016 Image006

We connected their noticings about the Pythagorean Theorem to come up with the equation of the circle.

3 Screen Shot 2016-03-04 at 9.47.46 AM

Students moved a circle around in the coordinate plane to notice and note what happens with the location of the circle, size of the circle, and equation of the circle.

15 Screen Shot 2016-03-04 at 11.01.34 AM

And then most of them told me the equation of a circle with center (h,k) and radius r, along with giving us the opportunity to think about whether square of (x-h) is equivalent to the square of (h-x).

16 Screen Shot 2016-03-04 at 10.58.42 AM.png

And so the journey continues … with an emphasis on noticing and noting.

 

 

 
2 Comments

Posted by on March 19, 2016 in Circles, Geometry

 

Tags: , , , , , ,

Notice and Note: Dilations

Are you familiar with Notice & Note: Strategies for Close Reading? Here’s a link to Heinemann’s Notice & Note learning community, and here’s a sample PDF. I wonder whether our Standards for Mathematical Practice are similar to the Notice and Note literary signposts.

It’s not enough to just read a text. We want students to read for understanding and comprehension. The literary signposts help students with close reading of a literary text.

Similarly, it’s not enough to just explore math with dynamic graphs and geometry. We want students to explore for understanding and comprehension. The math practices help students learn how to interact with a mathematical problem or concept … and what to notice.

 

Last week, we explored dilations.

What do you need for a dilation?

A figure, a point (which we’ll call the center of dilation), and a number (which we’ll call the scale factor)

We used our dynamic geometry software to perform a dilation.

1 11-15-2015 Image001

About what things might you be curious as you explore dilations?

(I thought of Kristin when I used the word curious.)

What happens when the center of dilation is inside the pre-image?

What happens when the center of dilation is on the pre-image? (on a side, on a vertex)

What happens when the scale factor is between 0 and 1?
What happens when the scale factor is negative?

How do the corresponding side lengths in the pre-image and image relate to each other?

 

I asked students to practice look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning as they explored the dilation. Do you know what it means to look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning?

Find a pattern.

Yes. Figure out what changes and what stays the same as you take a dynamic action on the dilation. Begin to make some generalizations about what you notice.

SMP8 #LL2LU Gough-Wilson.png

And don’t just notice, but actually note what you’re thinking.

The room got quiet as students noticed and noted their observations about dilations. I monitored student work both using Class Capture and walking around to see what students were noting.

(I promise I’ve tried to make it clear to students that dilation has 3 syllables and not 4 … but we do live in the South.)

Eventually, they shared some of their findings with their team, and then I selected a few to note their observations for the whole class.

BB showed us what happened when he perfomed a dilation with a scale factor of -1. He had noted that it was the same as rotating the pre-image 180˚ about the center of dilation.

SA talked with us about when the dilation would be a reduction. She had decided it wasn’t enough to say a scale factor less than 1 or a fractional scale factor but that we needed to say a scale factor between 0 and 1 or between -1 and 0.

FK showed us that when she drew a line connecting a pre-image point and its image, the line also contained the center of dilation.

PS noted that when the scale factor was 2, the length of the segment from the center of dilation to a pre-image point equaled the length of the segment from the pre-image point to its image.

When the scale factor was 3, the length of the segment from the center of dilation to a pre-image point equaled one-half the length of the segment from the pre-image point to its image.

 

We next determined a dilation and set of rigid motions would show that the two figures are similar.

20 Screenshot 2015-11-11 09.34.31

Translate ∆DET using vector EY.

21 Screen Shot 2015-11-17 at 5.25.08 AM

Rotate ∆D’E’T’ about Y using angle D’YA.

22 Screen Shot 2015-11-17 at 5.26.55 AM

Dilate ∆D’’E’’T’’ about Y using scale factor AY/D’’Y.

23 Screen Shot 2015-11-17 at 5.30.35 AM

Then we looked at dilations in the coordinate plane. I knew that my students had some experience with this from middle school, and so I sent a Quick Poll to see what they remembered.

24 Screenshot 2015-11-11 09.46.30

25 Screenshot 2015-11-11 09.46.13

Due to the success on the first question, I changed it up a bit with the second question.

26 Screenshot 2015-11-11 09.47.06

But I wonder now whether I should have started with the second question. If they could do the second question, doesn’t that tell me they can also do the first?

I’ve rearranged the polls to try that the next time I teach dilations.

 

We ended the lesson with a triangle that had been dilated. Where is the center of dilation?

And so the journey continues, with hope that noticing & noting will make a difference in what students learn and remember …

 
3 Comments

Posted by on November 17, 2015 in Dilations, Geometry

 

Tags: , , , , , , ,